Looking for a Keever SEO alternative?

Where Keever SEO is genuinely strong

Credit where it's due. Keever SEO competes directly with us in the Naples market, and they've earned a strong position in it. As of this writing they show up in the Naples map pack for SEO searches, they hold a 5.0 Google rating with the largest review count of any SEO company in Naples, and founder Scott Keever has real press behind him, including a Forbes Council membership. They also maintain a Clutch profile with client reviews on it. None of that is fluff, and we're not going to pretend otherwise.

We hold a 5.0 Google rating ourselves, on far fewer reviews, so on review volume alone Keever wins today. If review count and founder press are the signals you weight most, they deserve a serious look. The rest of this page covers the differences that don't show up in a star rating, and every one of them is something you can check yourself in about ten minutes with Google Maps and both websites.

Naples SEO vs Keever SEO, side by side

Here's how the two firms compare on concrete, verifiable points as of July 2026.

What a local presence looks like up close

Plenty of good agencies run lean or remote, and there's nothing wrong with that by itself. But if part of the reason you're shopping locally is that you want a Naples agency, it's worth looking at what "local" actually means for each firm.

Keever SEO's listed Naples address is 8971 Redonda Dr, a residential street about 25 to 30 minutes from central Naples. The phone number on their site is a toll-free 866 number. And their Naples page sits alongside more than 40 near-identical location pages for other cities, which tells you Naples is one market among many for them. That's a legitimate way to run an agency, and it clearly works for them. It's just a different thing than a firm built around one market.

Our office is a commercial suite at 4851 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 660, on the main commercial corridor in Naples, and our number is a local 239 line. Southwest Florida isn't one of our markets, it's the only one. Our Google Business Profile has been verified since 2011, and we've been helping local businesses get found online since then. When you call, you reach the people doing the work, in the market they work in every day.

The AI search difference

This is the clearest gap between the two service menus. Search is splitting into two channels. There's the classic map pack and blue links, and there's the growing world of AI answers in Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, where the answer usually cites only a handful of sources.

As of July 2026, Keever SEO's service menu doesn't list a GEO, AEO or AI-search service. We include AI search optimization in every plan, at every tier. In practice that means structuring your site, your content and your entity footprint so AI engines can read you, trust you and quote you when a Naples prospect asks a buying question. Whichever agency you choose, ask them exactly what they're doing to earn AI citations for your business. If the answer is vague, that channel isn't being worked.

Pricing, published and plain

Per their website, Keever SEO's local SEO starts around $1,000 per month. Our plans are published in full on our pricing page: Local at $750 per month, Growth at $1,500, and Dominate from $3,000. Every plan is month to month with no long-term contract, and every plan includes AI search optimization alongside the local SEO fundamentals.

We're also upfront about pacing. Expect roughly 90 days before results start to compound, because that's how local SEO actually behaves, for us and for anyone else. If a lower entry price with clearly published tiers matters to your budget, that's a real difference between the two firms. If it doesn't, weigh the other factors more heavily.

Who each agency is best for

We'd rather you pick the right fit than pick us for the wrong reasons, so here's our honest read.

Keever SEO is likely the better fit if:

• Review volume is your top trust signal. They have the largest Google review count of any SEO company in Naples, and that lead is real.
• Founder press and third-party profiles matter to your decision. Scott Keever's Forbes Council membership and their Clutch reviews are legitimate credentials.
• You like the idea of a firm that runs campaigns across dozens of city markets and brings that breadth to yours.

Naples SEO is likely the better fit if:

• You want an agency with a commercial office in town, a local 239 number, and Southwest Florida as its only market.
• You want AI search worked as a core service, not something missing from the menu.
• You want a published $750 entry point, month-to-month terms, and pricing you can read before anyone calls you.

One more piece of honesty: we're the newer name of the two in this market. Our first flagship client, SWFL Media Blasters, signed in June 2026, and you can see exactly what we built for them in our SWFL Media Blasters case study. Behind that, the team has built 100+ local business websites. Judge us on the work, not the review count, and judge Keever on the same standard.

How we work with SWFL businesses

• We start with an audit, not a pitch. Before talking strategy we look at where you actually stand in classic search and in AI answers, then show you the gaps. You can request one on our free SEO audit page.
• We pick the right scope for your stage. A solo roofer and a multi-location practice need different things, so plans are matched to where your business actually is, not to what a sales script says.
• We report on leads, not just rankings. Rankings matter, but the question we answer every month is whether the phone is ringing more and where those calls came from.
• We stay industry-specific. A seawall contractor in Cape Coral and a med spa in Bonita Springs get content and pages written in their own vocabulary, for their own buyers.

However you decide, put the same hard questions to both firms. Our list of questions to ask an SEO company works on us just as well as it works on Keever or anyone else. Two good agencies can both be worth a call. Make them both earn it.

Frequently asked questions